Nikon D3 Noise

The D3 is the digital camera flagship from Nikon. Regarding sensor noise and full size sensor Nikon was some years behind its competitor Canon. The D3 is a fine camera with a proud price. It has a full frame sensor (36x24mm) with 12.1 megapixel (4256 x 2832 px) resolution. One pixel measuers about 8.4 x 8.4 μm and is relatively large. This and because they switched from CCD to CMOS technology made it possible to decrease the noise dramatically. 12 megapixel for a picture is more than enough for the most purposes. The Nikon D3X has twice the pixels but more noise at higher ISO rates.

Fig. 1 shows a series of dark frames with different sensor sensitivities and exposure times. The camera settings were:

Optimize Image               : normal
Long Exposure Noise Reduction: no
Image Quality                : RAW
White Balance                : auto

All dark frames were take at room temperature (about 20 degrees celsius). These are not exact laboratory conditions but good enough for a qualitative conclusion. I began with the longest exposure time at the highest ISO rate so one cannot argue that the camera heated up during the whole series. I gave the camera some time to coool down between every picture and the camera was locked in a closet so that no light could get in. The pictures are untreated, except for scaling.

ISO 400ISO 800ISO 1600ISO 3200ISO 6400
8' 8 min @ ISO 400 8 min @ ISO 800 8 min @ ISO 1600 8 min @ ISO 3200 8 min @ ISO 6400
15' 15 min @ ISO 400 15 min @ ISO 800 15 min @ ISO 1600 15 min @ ISO 3200 15 min @ ISO 6400
30' 30 min @ ISO 400 30 min @ ISO 800 30 min @ ISO 1600 30 min @ ISO 3200 30 min @ ISO 6400
Fig. 1: Nikon D3 dark frames with different exposures and ISO rates. Whole frame scaled down to 150x100 pixel.

It is clearly visible that the sensor edges are heated up by surrounding electronics and glow pink. Once these are too bright (burned out) it is not possible to remove these without quality loss from the original image by subtracting the dark frame. In the case of the D3 one has to cut off the edge or choose a shorter exposure time. If one looks at always the same part in the center of the image one sees some hot pixels. These can be subtracted from the original image using a dark frame.

ISO 400ISO 800ISO 1600ISO 3200ISO 6400
8' 8 min @ ISO 400 8 min @ ISO 800 8 min @ ISO 1600 8 min @ ISO 3200 8 min @ ISO 6400
15' 15 min @ ISO 400 15 min @ ISO 800 15 min @ ISO 1600 15 min @ ISO 3200 15 min @ ISO 6400
30' 30 min @ ISO 400 30 min @ ISO 800 30 min @ ISO 1600 30 min @ ISO 3200 30 min @ ISO 6400
Fig. 2: Nikon D3 dark frames with different exposures and ISO rates. 150x100 pixel center crop.

Compare the noise and pink glow to older Nikon DSLR cameras. The Nikon D70 and D200 both have a CCD sensor in DX format (ca. 24x16mm), the Nikon D3 has a new CMOS sensor in full format (36x24mm). The noise has become much less thanks to new image sensor technology and bigger pixels. Also the pink glow from the surrounding electronic's heat has almost gone. On the older cameras the image has almost burned out after 30 minutes at highest sensitivity.

 Nikon D70Nikon D200Nikon D3
30 min
ISO 200
Nikon D70: 30m @ ISO 200 Nikon D200: 30m @ ISO 200 Nikon D3: 30m @ ISO 200
30 min
ISO 400
Nikon D70: 30m @ ISO 400 Nikon D200: 30m @ ISO 400 Nikon D3: 30m @ ISO 400
30 min
ISO 800
Nikon D70: 30m @ ISO 800 Nikon D200: 30m @ ISO 800 Nikon D3: 30m @ ISO 800
30 min
ISO 1600
Nikon D70: 30m @ ISO 1600 Nikon D200: 30m @ ISO 1600 Nikon D3: 30m @ ISO 1600
Fig. 3: Dark frame comparision of different Nikon SLR cameras.

Shown below is the enlarged Nikon D3 dark frame '30min @ ISO 3200'. One can recognize the pink glow on the sensor edge and an interesting pattern with a rectangular structure. Maybe this is caused by slight variations in the substrate.

30 min @ ISO 3200
Fig. 4: Nikon D3 dark frame, 30min @ ISO 3200 (full resolution, JPEG 4256x2832 9.7MB)

Links